Wittgenstein Reads Freud: The Myth of the Unconscious by Carol Cosman, Jacques Bouveresse

By Carol Cosman, Jacques Bouveresse

Did Freud current a systematic speculation in regards to the subconscious, as he continually maintained and as lots of his disciples retain repeating? this query has lengthy caused debates in regards to the legitimacy and usability of psychoanalysis, and it truly is of extreme significance to Lacanian analysts, whose major undertaking has been to emphasize Freud's medical grounding. the following Jacques Bouveresse, a famous authority on Ludwig Wittgenstein, contributes to the talk by way of turning to this Austrian-born thinker and modern of Freud for a candid evaluation of the early concerns surrounding psychoanalysis. Wittgenstein, who himself had introduced a devastating critique of conventional philosophy, sympathetically reflected Freud's declare to have produced a systematic thought in providing a brand new version of the human psyche. What Wittgenstein recognized--and what Bouveresse so eloquently stresses for today's reader--is that psychoanalysis doesn't target to provide a metamorphosis restricted to the mind yet quite seeks to impress an actual switch of human attitudes. the wonder in the back of the speculation of the subconscious for Wittgenstein is that it breaks clear of clinical, causal causes to supply new kinds of considering and conversing, or quite, a brand new mythology.

Offering a serious view of the entire texts within which Wittgenstein mentions Freud, Bouveresse immerses us within the highbrow weather of Vienna within the early a part of the 20 th century. even if we come to work out why Wittgenstein didn't view psychoanalysis as a technological know-how right, we're still made to believe the philosopher's experience of ask yourself and recognize for the cultural job Freud took on as he stumbled on new methods meaningfully to debate human matters. Intertwined during this tale of Wittgenstein's grappling with the idea of the subconscious is the tale of ways he got here to query the authority of technological know-how and of philosophy itself. whereas aiming basically on the rationalization of Wittgenstein's opinion of Freud, Bouveresse's ebook should be learn as a problem to the French psychoanalytic tuition of Lacan and as a provocative statement on cultural authority.

Show description

Read Online or Download Wittgenstein Reads Freud: The Myth of the Unconscious PDF

Similar psychoanalysis books

Interrogating the Real

Slavoj Žižek is without doubt one of the world's most well known cultural commentators: a prolific author and philosopher, whose vividly adventurous, unorthodox and wide-ranging writings have gained him a distinct position as probably the most excessive profile thinkers of our time. masking psychoanalysis, philosophy and pop culture and drawing on a heady mixture of Marxist politics, Hegelian dialectics and Lacanian psychoanalysis, the writings gathered in Interrogating the true mirror not just the outstanding volume of Žižek's diverse pursuits, but additionally demonstrate his arguable and dynamic sort.

Death and Identity: Being and the Psycho-Sexual Drama

It is a choice of articles through the eminent French psychoanalyst Michel de M'Uzan, collated from quite a few assets initially released by means of Gallimard. this can be the 1st time those articles and essays come in English and seem as a part of the IPA's influential Psychoanalytic rules and purposes sequence, the purpose of that's to target the medical creation of vital authors whose works are extraordinary contributions to the advance of the psychoanalytic box and to set out correct rules and subject matters, generated through the historical past of psychoanalysis, that should be mentioned by means of current psychoanalysts.

The Routledge Handbook of Psychoanalysis in the Social Sciences and Humanities

The Routledge guide of Psychoanalysis within the Social Sciences and arts offers a finished, serious review of the historic, theoretical and utilized types of psychoanalytical feedback. This path-breaking instruction manual bargains scholars new methods of realizing the powers and boundaries of psychoanalysis, and of the social, cultural and political probabilities of psychoanalytic critique.

Imaginary Ethnographies: Literature, Culture, and Subjectivity

Via readings of iconic figures equivalent to the cannibal, the kid, the alien, and the posthuman, Gabriele Schwab analyzes literary explorations on the barriers of the human. Treating literature as a dynamic medium that "writes culture"―one that makes the summary specific and native, and situates us in the world―Schwab pioneers a compelling method of studying literary texts as "anthropologies of the long run" that problem routine productions of which means and data.

Extra resources for Wittgenstein Reads Freud: The Myth of the Unconscious

Example text

Even on the closest possible examination, there is no perceptible difference in the length of the ash between the two photos. Whatever has just happened, or is about to happen, has to be inferred: from the hand with the cigar, from the walking sticks, from the jacket or cape loose over Heinrich Graf’s left shoulder as if he had just sat down. If there was a walk, it could have been anywhere, by the lake or into the woods. Every moment contains its predecessors, is compacted with its history, and most of it leaks out into the outside world without leaving any trace.

Despite the blurring and grain of these two images, we can just make out the cigar in Freud’s left hand, distinguishable mainly by its tip of grey ash. Even on the closest possible examination, there is no perceptible difference in the length of the ash between the two photos. Whatever has just happened, or is about to happen, has to be inferred: from the hand with the cigar, from the walking sticks, from the jacket or cape loose over Heinrich Graf’s left shoulder as if he had just sat down. If there was a walk, it could have been anywhere, by the lake or into the woods.

1897) Nothing about old photos is self-evident. Or whatever seems obvious is only half the story. It has previously been accepted that this photo shows Freud at Berggasse among his possessions. He looks at home and the pictures on the wall behind relate him to his holidays. Yet contextual and architectural details tell another story. For the time being, the best hypothesis, and one which would have the great merit of also explaining the absence of pinholes, is that this photo might have been taken at Alexander’s place.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.56 of 5 – based on 9 votes